Story Board on Prezi
Reality is Broken: A Review and Comparison
Why McGonigal is Wrong
In Reality is Broken, Why Games Make Us Better and How They Can Change the World by Jane McGonigal there is an impressive amount of statistics about the amount of time the average gamer plays video games. In fact, the amount of time is so impressive that it has led Jane McGonigal to come to the conclusion that reality is broken and therefore people have turned to virtual worlds to satisfy their worldly needs.
From this idea, McGonigal further discovered that there is a ridiculous amount of human participation hours being committed to playing a single game: World of Warcraft. On average gamers are committing 210 participation hours per week to playing WoW. This visual is meant to be a story board of a greater visual that has the potential to show an overwhelming statistic and what that number could mean if it were applied to worldly problems outside of gaming.
Included after the jump is a review of the book and how McGonigal's evaluation that video games and gamers are the future of our society can be applied to professional writers. This review is intended for all audiences, but is specifically geared towards helping people outside of the profession to understand the specifics of how a professional writer creates and designs successful documentation.
Reality is Broken: A Review and Comparison
In Jane McGonigal’s book Reality is Broken, she shows the reader
that “the future will belong to those who can understand, design, and play
games.” In a future where video games are becoming an integral part of everyday
life and advanced thinking, one must ask where this puts professional writers.
I believe, after having read Reality is Broken, that people involved
with the video game industry and professional writers have been doing the same
job for years, just under different terms. Without having realized it,
McGonigal has actually written a book that serves a dual purpose; introducing
the world to the idea that gamers hold the key to advanced thinking and also
unintentionally describing the most basic aspects of what is involved with
being a professional writer. From this book we can see that the reasons why
video game developers and gamers are revolutionizing the ways we think are on
par with the reasons that professional writers are becoming a vital part of the
workforce.
Why Video Games are Successful
Throughout the first
two sections of the book McGonigal is setting the reader up to understand why
it is gamers have chosen to break away from reality and immerse themselves in
fictional worlds. In sticking with her title for the book she argues that
reality is in fact broken and no longer satisfies the needs of advanced
thinkers; i.e. the gamers. “Games are providing rewards that reality is not.
They are teaching and inspiring and engaging us in ways that reality is not.
They are bringing us together in ways that reality is not (4).” Games have
become so efficient at doing the job they set forth that people are moving
their lives from the real world and are spending more time out of their day
playing games in a virtual world.
In moving to the third
part of the book McGonigal elaborates on what it is that makes video games so
efficient at their intended job: they are able to effectively engage their
audience. She achieves this by explaining “How Very Big Games Can Change the
World;” i.e. how gamers have become a “valuable–and largely untapped– source of
participation bandwidth (232).” The best example of how gamers’ untapped value
can be effectively utilized is through crowdsourcing. “Crowdsourcing is a way
to do collectively, faster, better, and more cheaply what might otherwise be
impossible for a single organization to do alone (220).” But, as McGonigal
points out, in order for crowdsourcing to be effective the organization has to
be able to make the crowdsourcing interface as engaging as possible. By
engagement, McGonigal doesn’t mean just being able to hold the users attention
for a certain span of time, but instead means actively figuring “out how to
capture the mental energy... (228)” of the intended audience.
This concept is easily
applied to professional writing and is becoming a key component to creating
successful documentation. While we always intend to engage our audience, we do
not always think: to what level do we want to them be engaged? McGonigal argues
that “if crowdsourcing is the theory, then games are the platform.” This is
something that professional writers need to take note of because video games incorporate
many different aspects that allow for successful engagement in crowdsourcing projects.
Video games create in-depth worlds that allow their players to feel actively
involved with. Professional writers can look to this and find inspiration for
creating and designing documents that revolve around the engagement level their
audience desires.
While McGonigal is
explaining why video games are the key to making crowdsourcing effective, she
dives into reasoning why video games provide an infinitely renewable resource
for gratification. As a part of her reasoning she gives an actual job listing for
a position at Bungie. The listing reads:
“Do you dream about creating
worlds imbued with real value and consequence? Can you find the fine line
between a reward that encourages players to have fun and an incentive that
enslaves them? Can you devise a way for a player to grow while preserving a
delicate game balance? If you answered yes to these questions, you might want
to polish up your résumé and apply to be Bungie’s next Player Investment Design
Lead.
The Player Investment Design Lead
directs a group of designers responsible for founding a robust and rewarding
investment path, supported by consistent, rich and secure incentives that drive
player behavior toward having fun and investing in their characters, and then
validates those systems through intense simulation, testing and iteration (244).”
She goes on to say
that “this kind of job doesn’t yet exist outside of the game industry (244).”
As a professional writer, this struck me as very odd. McGonigal has blatantly
outlined all of the most important roles that a successful professional writer
needs to fill. The Player Investment Design Lead (PIDL) has to read their
audience so well that they are able to “enslave” the players’ mind while
simultaneously making the player feel enjoyment. In the same way, when creating
a successful document a professional writer must be hyper aware of their
audience and the audience’s needs. If effective, the professional writer will
have captured their audience’s attention all the while keeping the audience so
riveted that they don’t notice that their minds have been “enslaved.”
The PIDL also has to
be creative enough that they can construct elaborate in-game worlds that
reflect real world “value and consequence.” The professional writer has to be
able to market their documents to their audience in a way that is not only
creative, but innovative enough that the audience feels like they are
experiencing something they have never seen before; even if the document is
based off of ideas and concepts that are trending. In this way the professional
writer has to create a “world” for the document to exist in while still holding
to values (read: ideas) that we are already familiar with.
The job listing also
states that the PIDL needs to “validate those systems through intense
simulation, testing and iteration (244).” The intricate and carefully created
world that the PIDL designs cannot just be thrown into a game and deemed successful.
The system has to go through beta stages, rigorous user testing, and then
revised before it can actually be called complete. The process is the same for
the professional writer. In devising a document, the professional writer always
has their intended audience in mind, but this does not mean that they
successfully reach the audience on their first attempt. Documents are tested,
usability tests are conducted, and the work done has to be revised before it
can be comprehensive enough to be implemented in real world situations.
Conclusion
Readers of this book,
and especially this review, should be able to take away that video games are
effectively achieving levels of engagement that is becoming harder to attain
every day. The implications of this is that, as professional writers, we should
be able to see what makes the video game so successful and be able to apply it
to our processes while making documentation. Readers should also be able to
take away a further and more relatable understanding of just what it is
professional writers do. There is a perceived “mystery” to how successful
documentation gets created and by looking at how video game developers create a
prosperous and engaging scenario we can learn more about the process a
professional writer takes to create and design effective documentation.
Source
McGonigal,
J. (2011). Reality is Broken, Why Games Make Us Better
and How They Can Change the World. New York, NY: Penguin Pr.
No comments:
Post a Comment